BUnow News


Opinion and Editorial Sports

Derek Jeter is Engaged: So Let’s Look at his Impressive List of Ex-Girlfriends

Derek Jeter is known by most for his Hall of Fame worthy baseball career with the New York Yankees that came to an hannah and derekend with the closing of the 2014 MLB season. Jeter played in the league for 20 years and is the proud owner of five MLB World Series rings and holds numerous Yankees and MLB postseason records. However, Jeter is also well known for his success in the dating field.

Jeter recently put a ring on the successful Sports Illustrated 2015 cover model, Hannah Davis. The couple have been on and off since 2012, but it seems Jeter is finally ready to settle down. While we wish Davis and Jeter the very best in their engagement and marriage, let’s take this time to look back on Jeter’s extremely successful dating career.

It isn’t just the sheer numbers or the amount of girls Jeter has ‘known,’ because that in itself is worthy of an article; but rather the caliber of the famous and talented woman in his star studded lineup. Jeter has dated some of the most coveted and beautiful women on this earth to date. Below is a list of the top ten women Jeter has had the pleasure of dating:

  1. Vanessa Minnillo


Current wife of Nick Lachey, Vanessa Minnillo dated Jeter back in 2003. Their relationship was considered very on and off. Minnillo is well known for hosting MTV’s popular afternoon show TRL (Total Request Live) and also for holding the title of former Miss Teen USA.

  1. Tyra Banks


Iconic model and TV personality, Banks, was rumored to have spent some time with Jeter. However, both deny ever hooking up.

  1. Lara Dutta


Dutta, Miss Universe 2000, also spent some time with Jeter. Reportedly, Jeter saw her on the daytime talk show Live With Regis and Kathie Lee, and shortly after sent her tickets to attend one of his games. They dated for around a year.

  1. Jordana Brewster


Brewster is well known for her reoccurring role in the Fast & Furious movies. Like the women on the rest of this list, she also dated Jeter back in 2003. Obviously they did not work out, but regardless she had nothing bad to say about him. Years later, she said, “I still like the Yankees. And he’s a great guy!” Jeter, you can do no wrong.

  1. Scarlett Johansson


Johansson and Jeter were spotted out to dinner in 2004, however, this is another case where both deny ever hooking up. It is safe to say that no one believes them.

  1. Mariah Carey

mariah carey

Singer/songwriter, Carey, had the pleasure of being Jeter’s first celebrity girlfriend. They dated back in 1996-1998 when they were both at the very top of their games. Jeter was named rookie of the year in 1996 and went on to assist the Yankees in winning their first World Series in 18 years. The fact that they were both just starting out in their careers probably contributed to their breakup. How can you blame them?

  1. Jessica Biel


Biel and Jeter dated in 2006 for about a year right when 7th Heaven was wrapping up and Biel was at the peak of her career.

  1. Jessica Alba

jessica alba

The Alba and Jeter fling of 2004 didn’t last very long, but regardless, it happened. Two of the hottest Jessica’s on the planet in two years… killing it, Jeter.

  1. Minka Kelly


The Friday Night Lights actress, Minka Kelly, began dating Jeter in 2008. Before his new fiancé, Davis, she may have been his longest and most serious relationship to date. It is not hard to guess why: Kelly was named the sexiest woman in the world by Esquire in 2010. The couple dated for three years and engagement rumors even spread around in 2010, however, we all know how this relationship ended. Sadly.

  1. Adriana Lima

adriana lima

Even if they were only linked briefly, Lima has to be at the top of this list. The Victoria’s Secret Model and Jeter dated for a short amount of time back in 2006. However, Lima was a well-known virgin at the time, who strongly believes sex should be left until after marriage. She told GQ magazine, “Sex is for after marriage… [Guys] have to respect that this is my choice. If there’s no respect, that means they don’t want me.” You can probably take a guess why the two of them did not work out.

(Hannah Davis)


We now have to give the Sports Illustrated model, Davis, the credit she deserves. Regardless of Jeter’s extremely impressive ex-girlfriend lineup, she is the one who Jeter finally decided to settle down with; and I am sure there is no one out there who is asking why.

The beautiful and talented model has been dating Jeter off and on since 2012. Jeter reportedly proposed to Davis at the end of October 2015. The 25-year-old model is one of the fashion industry’s top women, appearing in campaigns for Victoria’s Secret, Tommy Hilfiger, Levi’s and of course Sports Illustrated.

BUnow wishes them a life full of happiness. Don’t forget to comment below with who you think is Jeter’s hottest ex-girlfriend.